7 Best Insurance CRM Software for Agents, Brokers & Teams

7 Best Insurance CRM Software for Agents, Brokers & Teams

Aug 15, 2023
2 minute read
Selling Signals content and product recommendations are editorially independent. We may make money when you click on links to our partners. Learn More

Insurance CRMs are sales software that help insurance agents, brokers, and teams manage their sales process and ongoing client relationships. Available to the insurance industry are general-use CRMs providing solid sales and marketing features as well as industry-specific insurance CRM software that include niche functions like commission management and claim resolution. To help you choose the best, we evaluated seven options that stood out the most.

Here are the top seven insurance CRM software for agents, brokers, and teams:

  • Freshsales: Best overall software for features, pricing, and usability (free starting price)
  • Zoho CRM: Best for client communication across multiple channels (free starting price)
  • Pipedrive: Best insurance CRM software option with add-on features (14-day free trial)
  • HubSpot CRM: Best free insurance software with premium upgrades (free starting price)
  • Salesforce Financial Services Cloud: Best for advanced, custom features (30-day trial)
  • NextAgency: Best for agent commission tracking and management (14-day free trial)
  • Insureio: Best for industry-specific sales and marketing automations (30-day free trial)

Freshsales emerged as the top overall insurance software, even though it’s a general CRM. Our list of the best insurance software included only two industry-specific options because they tend to be more expensive and have limited general CRM features. Continue reading to see each software’s use case, pricing, and key features, or skip down to see our scoring logic.

Note: All per-user prices are with a one-year commitment unless noted.

Top 4 Insurance CRM Features

The best CRM software for insurance agents and companies include:

Monitor commissions for agents and insurance products, and use this information to gain insights into your revenue and the success of your marketing campaigns.

How We Evaluated the Best Insurance CRM Software

When comparing the top insurance CRM software options, we assessed both general and industry-specific options based on six weighted categories, using key subcriteria in each category to assign every option a score out of five. We then used these scores to determine a primary use case for each of our top options to help you choose the best for you.

Evaluation Criteria

The best CRM software for insurance agents and agencies are reasonably priced, simple to use and implement, and not lacking in essential tools. Hence, we placed the most emphasis on core features and cost, followed by customization capabilities and third-party integrations. Finally, we looked into each option’s ease of use and the quality of customer support solutions offered.

Methodology weights
Core Features 25%
Cost 20%
Customization 15%
Integration 15%
Ease of Use 15%
Customer Support 10%

We looked for general CRM features (like contact management and multichannel engagement) plus insurance-specific functions (such as claims management and commission tracking).

This entails monthly costs, free options (trials and/or free-for-life platforms), billing options, and any mandatory setup costs.

Winner Criteria Winner: Multiple winners

This measures how much users can make a CRM software their own — from customizing reports and dashboards to creating client financial profiles.

Here, we assessed how each CRM software syncs with Zapier and insurance software or other apps for communication, social media, and accounting.

Winner Criteria Winner: Multiple winners

We took user feedback and ratings from credible review sites into consideration and evaluated each CRM's knowledge base.

Winner Criteria Winner: Freshsales →

We considered the quality of each CRM’s support channels via phone, email, and live chat and also assessed real user reviews on reputable sites.

Winner Criteria Winner: Pipedrive →
Advertisement

Bottom Line: Best Insurance CRM Software

Whether you’re a team of one or one hundred, a reliable insurance CRM is a must if you want to grow your client list and maintain a solid customer base. Think about the areas where your company could use the most help — we’re confident that any of the options featured on our list can provide you with the right tools to help you reach your goals. If you’re looking for a more general option, check out our list of the best overall CRMs for salespeople and teams.

Alison Barretta

Alison is a Philadelphia-based technology writer for Selling Signals. She has 15 years of experience in the digital space, and her specialties include comparison guides and reviews across CRM, ecommerce, and various SaaS products. In her free time, Alison has received two HubSpot certifications plus a TEFL certification, as well as leads an online martial arts learning program.

Recommended for you...

The 6 Best Headless CMS for B2B Teams in 2026
Faithe Day
Mar 9, 2026
Best Marketing CRM Software for 2026: Top Picks for Modern Marketing Teams
HubSpot CRM Review 2026: Pros, Cons, Pricing, and How It Aligns Sales and Marketing
8 Best CRM for Freelancers Who Want More Repeat Clients
Selling Signals Logo

Selling Signals delivers actionable advice for sales and marketing professionals. Learn strategies that help you hit targets, strengthen customer relationships, and win more business. Get expert advice on lead generation, sales processes, CRM software, sales management, and account management directly to your inbox.

Property of TechnologyAdvice. © 2026 TechnologyAdvice. All Rights Reserved

Advertiser Disclosure: Some of the products that appear on this site are from companies from which TechnologyAdvice receives compensation. This compensation may impact how and where products appear on this site including, for example, the order in which they appear. TechnologyAdvice does not include all companies or all types of products available in the marketplace.